Image (Credit): Hubble Space Telescope image of the globular star cluster called Messier 30, also called NGC 7099. (ESA/Hubble & NASA, M. Libralato, G. Piotto, A. Sarajedini)
If at first you don’t succeed, then try, try again. But be sure to learn from your mistakes, which are still fresh in everyone’s minds.
Launched in 1990, the space telescope has been responsible for an amazing array of new discoveries, and it can continue to assist astronomers if a way is found to get it back into a more stable orbit.
That is why NASA has recently issued a Request for Information to learn more about what can be done. It is interested in three areas:
potentially conducting a mission to boost Hubble to a higher altitude to extend its science lifetime;
servicing Hubble to enhance its capabilities; or
performing a safe, controlled re-entry into Earth’s atmosphere or orbital disposal at the end of Hubble’s mission.
Let’s hope for some worthwhile ideas for the first two items. As Nicky Fox, associate administrator, Science Mission Directorate, NASA Headquarters in Washington, stated:
Hubble is a national icon that has fundamentally changed how humanity views our universe for more than 35 years…Commercial industry has rapidly evolved in recent years to offer new capabilities for in-space satellite capture and servicing. Given the time we have until Hubble’s anticipated re-entry, we are eager to explore the breadth of possibilities to boost Hubble to a higher orbit while we develop the flagship mission to follow.
The one glitch was the booster’s self-destruction rather than its capture.
All in all, it was a good day for SpaceX and NASA with Artemis III on the horizon.
Is the capture of the rocket really necessary? Not really. In my opinion, it is a bit of a show and an unnecessary threat to ground equipment. Both the booster and rocket have the ability to land without being captured mid-air and risking the loss of the launch tower, which makes a little more sense.
Many argue that the capture allows for a rapid rocket turnaround, and SpaceX is talking about 10,000 annual launches of the Starship by 2030, or one launch per hour. This volume seems to be an unrealistic wish (like many Musk ideas), mainly aimed at commercial rather that NASA needs, and, as noted, dangerous if one landing rocket can destroy the launch tower, thereby stopping launches altogether.
Regardless of the show Musk is currently putting on for investors, I am more interested in the upcoming Moon mission. We do not need 10,000 launches – we need a series of strategic launches to put equipment and humans on the lunar surface. That should be the focus for the moment. Can anyone tell this to Mr. Musk? And will he listen?
Image (Credit): December 5, 2022 view of the Earth and Moon from the camera aboard NASA’s Orion Spacecraft during the Artemis I mission. (NASA)
“Two years, we went from Apollo 4, an uncrewed mission, to Apollo 11, where our astronauts were landing and walking on the moon here. Let’s not just take the idea that we should be trying to do things on a reasonable timeline means it is inherently unsafe. That’s an insult to everyone that comes to NASA and industry, and certainly the pioneers from decades past that know how this is done.”
-Statement by NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman in response from a question by WESH 2 news about safety versus speed. This comes the same week that NASA is seeking bids on $10 billion in new contracts for lunar cargo flights. Given the number of companies involved, it appears NASA will have the support it needs. But while the Moon missions are going well, SpaceX’s recent announcement that it is retiring its Falcon 9 rocket and Dragon capsule may put travel to the International Space Station (ISS) at risk. It will be strange if the US can get to the Moon but not the ISS.
It would be great if NASA had a number of rocket suppliers run by boring corporate types who competently provided a service and then quietly went home to their families each night. But we don’t. NASA as well as the Department of Defense have become more and more reliant on one erratic man and one company for most of its rocket needs. This is a problem.
Elon Musk does not go home each night to relax with a drink or attend charitable events. No, he spends his time interfering in foreign affairs, be it Ukraine or England, while spending hundreds of millions of dollars on US elections. Even more troublesome, he joined the current administration to systematically destroy parts of the government based on incomplete, inaccurate or fabricated data. This is a problem.
So with the recent election and the coming change in Congress, what can we expect regarding Mr. Musk and SpaceX?
The newspapers are full of potential problems that were foreseeable yet ignored or hidden by the White House.
SpaceX Starlink: The new Congress is likely to open investigations on Mr. Musk’s involvement in the degradation of Starlink services shortly after President Trump announced plans to import Russian fuel while also telling Ukraine to cease the destruction of energy facilities in Russia – a country that continues to randomly murder Ukranian civilians.
As Silicon Valley’s elected members in Congress, we represent hundreds of innovation economy employers and workers whose livelihoods depend on the credibility of American technology abroad..Politically motivated service interruptions or erratic throttling will undermine reputations developed through decades of work that Americans have led to support our allies and customers throughout the world.
An October article in TheEconomist made it clear that Europe needed to move away from Starlink and Mr. Musk a well, stating:
Recent days have made clear the folly of relying too much for your national security on a capricious private citizen named Elon Musk.
Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE): The destruction of various government offices and services by DOGE, particularly the US Agency for International Development (USAID), as well as the potential misuse of private government data, will also be the subject of congressional investigations. Government audits have already determined DOGE activities were poorly documented and its findings overstated.
The DOGE chickens are coming home to roost. Elon Musk waved a chainsaw on stage and laughed while firing public servants and gutting the services Americans rely on. Then he lied to the American people about the savings. He must answer for it under oath.
SpaceX Rockets: Many on the Hill will question the risks associated with the government’s reliance on a single rocket company run by an individual with questionable ties to Russia’s President Putin. Former Clinton Labor Secretary Robert Reich has also called for the nationalization of SpaceX – an unlikely event, but an indication of the current mood among some Democrats.
Greater scrutiny of SpaceX’s government contracts were called for In the same letter noted above, with the Democratic Congressmen stated:
We will ensure that the 120th Congress will closely scrutinize federal funding awarded to Mr. Musk’s businesses, including whether these companies meet their contractual obligations, and whether adequate safeguards exist against political interference, arbitrary service restrictions, and misuse of federal resources.
Mr. Musk also shot himself in the foot by spending over $45 million on the recent Texas US Senate race only to see his candidate lose, in part because of the backlash against Musk’s excessive involvement. This lost race, as well as the election of a Democratic governor, is not good news for Texas-based SpaceX.
None of this will go away under the new Congress, and if the past is any guide, Mr. Musk’s attempts to try to make it go away will only make it worse for him and for the rest of us.
Note: I have seen various accounts regarding the amount that Mr. Musk spent on the election. According to Scripps New, the amount is estimated at about $474 million nationwide, with about $224 million targeted at Texas alone. Of that $224 million, at least $158 million was given to the Senate Republican super PAC.
“Every piece of this mission in Earth orbit is designed to reduce risk before we put astronauts back on the Moon…We’re launching three spacecraft on three different rockets and testing how they operate together — something NASA has never attempted. Every lesson we learn here gets us closer to landing on the Moon in 2028.”
–Statement by Jeremy Parsons, NASA’s Artemis program manager, regarding a planned 14-day test in 2027 of Blue Origin’s Blue Moon, SpaceX’s Starship, and NASA’s Orion capsule using three different rockets (Blue Origin’s New Glenn, SpaceX’s Starship, and NASA’s Space Launch System). See the NASA image above to understand the complexity of what is planned. You can also find more information about the mission here.